North and Lunsford's "The Idea of a Writing Center" and "Collaboration, Control, and the Idea of a Writing Center," respectively, provide a comprehensive look at the concept and function of a writing center. However, there are significant distinctions between the two approaches. North's approach to the writing center is educational, directing the reader to the center's actual purpose and what happens within it. Lunsford's approach is distinct in that she instead warns and explains the dangers of a writing center, which is markedly different from North's generally positive attitude. While some may view Lunsford's criticism as altogether negative, she is not entirely incorrect. Not only is the concept of an efficient, really collaborative writing center difficult to realize, but it is also costly. Instead of stimulating knowledge and innovation, it could be used to enforce hierarchical hierarchies, dampening education.
What might a fully digital writing center look like, I wonder?
Comments
Post a Comment